Knowledge Tree
Relations (1)
related 5.55 — strongly supporting 46 facts
The relationship between consciousness and matter is central to the panpsychist perspective, which posits that consciousness is an intrinsic property or hidden internal aspect of matter [1], [2], [3]. Various theories, such as Russellian monism and panprotopsychism, attempt to resolve the 'hard problem' by arguing that matter cannot be fully described without accounting for its consciousness-involving nature [4], [5], [6], [7].
Facts (46)
Sources
Critique of Panpsychism: Philosophical Coherence and Scientific ... thequran.love 14 facts
claimPanpsychists claim that by giving matter an experiential dimension, they achieve a unified theory of reality where the mental is woven into the fabric of existence.
claimPanpsychism posits that intrinsic properties of matter are or include experiential ones, arguing that because humans are instances of consciousness, this provides a substantive and non-arbitrary explanation for how matter feels from the inside and manifests as consciousness in complex brains.
claimPanpsychism posits consciousness or proto-consciousness as the hidden internal aspect of matter, suggesting that physics has a blindspot regarding the subjective reality behind equations.
claimDual-aspect monism, also known as neutral monism or Russellian panpsychism, posits that matter has two aspects: a quantitative, scientific aspect from the outside, and a conscious aspect from the inside.
claimPanpsychism proposes that consciousness is the hidden inner nature of matter, thereby attempting to integrate consciousness into the physical world.
perspectivePhilip Goff argues that by limiting physics to the quantitative aspects of matter, science rendered consciousness invisible to physical theory by design, leaving physics to describe what matter does rather than what it is intrinsically.
claimRussellian panpsychism differs from traditional dualism because it does not posit a separate substance of mind, and it differs from standard physicalism because it asserts that current physical science cannot fully describe matter without including consciousness.
claimPhilip Goff and Galen Strawson advocate for a neo-Russellian monist view of consciousness, which is based on Bertrand Russell's insight that physics reveals the structure of matter but not its intrinsic character.
perspectiveA functionalist perspective on matter suggests that asking "what is matter in itself?" is a wrong question, as matter is defined by its causal role, rendering the alleged gap between matter and consciousness illusory.
claimIn its contemporary form, panpsychism is presented as a response to the perceived failure of reductive physicalism to account for consciousness, proposing that consciousness is an intrinsic feature of matter.
perspectiveGalen Strawson characterizes the theory that consciousness emerges from non-conscious matter as 'brute emergence' or 'magic,' which he considers an incoherent approach.
claimPanpsychism eliminates the need to explain how consciousness emerges from non-conscious matter by asserting that consciousness exists in a basic form in all matter.
claimEstablishing a reliable indicator of minimal consciousness in a simple organism or an artificial micro-system could indirectly support the hypothesis that consciousness pervades matter.
claimIn Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz's view, while every portion of matter contains a hierarchy of monadic minds, only organized beings with a dominant monad, such as humans, animals, or plants, possess a unified consciousness.
Panpsychism - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org 6 facts
perspectiveSewall Wright endorsed a version of panpsychism, believing that consciousness is an inherent property of matter rather than a mysterious property that emerges at a certain level of material complexity.
perspectiveMax Tegmark disagrees with the conclusion that consciousness is an intrinsic property of matter, arguing instead that the universe is not just describable by mathematics but is mathematics itself.
claimBertrand Russell concluded that consciousness is related to the extrinsic properties of matter and labeled these intrinsic properties "quiddities".
referenceIn the book 'Mortal Questions' (1979), Thomas Nagel argues that panpsychism follows from four premises: (P1) everything that exists is material, (P2) consciousness is irreducible to lower-level physical properties, (P3) consciousness exists, and (P4) higher-order properties of matter can be reduced to lower-level properties.
claimIf premise (P4) is true, then consciousness must be a unique property of matter, which implies that panpsychism is true.
perspectiveGalen Strawson believes that consciousness "just is" matter, comparing the relationship to how mass is energy.
Panpsychism (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy/Fall 2015 Edition) plato.stanford.edu 4 facts
claimThe key difficulty in the philosophy of consciousness is explaining the generation of consciousness by 'mere matter' in naturalistic terms.
accountC. Lloyd Morgan, a radical emergentist, retreated into a Spinozistic parallelism of mind and matter due to concerns regarding the emergence of consciousness.
claimBecause the only intrinsic nature humans are familiar with is consciousness, and matter must be assigned some intrinsic nature, the intrinsic nature argument suggests that matter must be granted a mentalistic intrinsic nature.
perspectivePanpsychism possesses a metaphysical advantage over emergentism because it avoids the difficulty of explaining how consciousness emerges from matter and the risk of making emergent features causally impotent or epiphenomenal.
Panpsychism - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy plato.stanford.edu 3 facts
claimRussellian monists argue that the problem of consciousness arises because physical science remains silent on the intrinsic, concrete, or categorical features of matter.
claimRussellian panprotopsychism posits that the intrinsic nature of fundamental matter involves non-phenomenal properties that explain the reality of consciousness.
claimRussellian panpsychism posits that the intrinsic nature of fundamental matter is itself consciousness-involving.
Is Reality an Illusion? New Theory Challenges Modern Physics scitechdaily.com 2 facts
quoteMaria Strømme stated regarding her theory: "Yes, you could say so. But above all, it is a theory in which consciousness comes first, and structures such as time, space and matter arise afterwards. It is a very ambitious attempt to describe how our experienced reality functions."
claimMaria Strømme, a Professor of Materials Science at Uppsala University, proposes a theoretical model in AIP Advances where consciousness is the fundamental element of reality, from which time, space, and matter arise.
Panpsychism (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy/Fall 2025 Edition) plato.stanford.edu 2 facts
perspectivePhilip Goff (2016, 2017, 2019a) argues that because the intrinsic nature of brain matter is consciousness-involving, the most simple and parsimonious hypothesis is that matter outside of brains also possesses a consciousness-involving nature.
perspectiveThe panpsychist perspective proposes that the intrinsic nature of matter is, at least in part, consciousness.
Theories and Methods of Consciousness biomedres.us 2 facts
Consciousness-Induced Quantum State Reduction - Nova Spivack novaspivack.com 2 facts
claimThe mind-matter problem is addressed by proposing a form of psycho-physical interaction grounded in shared geometric principles, where consciousness (characterized by Ω and Ψ) and matter (described by quantum fields) are both describable in terms of information geometry.
claimThe interaction mechanism between consciousness and matter arises from the geometric coupling (Ω_coupling, Ĥ_interaction) between the informational structure of the conscious observer and the quantum system, rather than an ad hoc mental force.
Consciousness (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy/Fall 2025 ... plato.stanford.edu 2 facts
claimIn his 1720 work, Monadology, G.W. Leibniz used the analogy of a mill to argue that consciousness cannot arise from mere matter, asserting that an observer walking through the mechanical operations of an expanded brain would not see any conscious thoughts.
perspectiveJohn Locke avoided making hypotheses regarding the substantial basis of consciousness and its relationship to matter, though he considered consciousness essential to both thought and personal identity.
Quantum Models of Consciousness from a Quantum Information ... arxiv.org 1 fact
claimJohnjoe McFadden discussed the distinction between matter and electromagnetic fields in the context of consciousness in 2023.
A new theoretical model proposes consciousness as the ... - Facebook facebook.com 1 fact
claimA new theoretical model proposes that consciousness is the fundamental basis of reality, existing prior to time, space, and matter.
Panpsychism - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy plato.stanford.edu 1 fact
claimEmergentism faces the challenge of explaining how consciousness emerges from matter without rendering emergent features causally impotent or epiphenomenal.
Quantum Approaches to Consciousness plato.stanford.edu 1 fact
claimThere are three basic types of quantum approaches to consciousness: (1) consciousness is a manifestation of quantum processes in the brain, (2) quantum concepts are used to understand consciousness without referring to brain activity, and (3) matter and consciousness are regarded as dual aspects of one underlying reality.
Dualism (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy/Winter 2016 Edition) plato.stanford.edu 1 fact
claimThe 'ectoplasm' account of substance dualism is criticized because it fails to explain why this specific 'stuff' supports consciousness any better than ordinary matter does.
Good Old-Fashioned Artificial Consciousness and the Intermediate ... frontiersin.org 1 fact
claimThe authors define consciousness as a physical property that is measurable, observable, causally active, located in space-time, and composed of matter or energy.
Psychology and Cognitive Science on Consciousness klinikong.com 1 fact
claimFundamental questions regarding the nature of consciousness and its relationship to matter continue to challenge researchers in the fields of cognitive science and psychology.
Consciousness as the foundation: New theory addresses nature of ... phys.org 1 fact
referenceMaria Strømme's theoretical framework posits that consciousness is not a byproduct of brain activity, but rather a fundamental field underlying all experience, including matter, space, time, and life itself.
The Hard Problem of Consciousness | Springer Nature Link link.springer.com 1 fact
claimNatural sciences have historically attempted to explain the mind by reducing it to a byproduct of matter, operating under the assumption that matter is simpler to analyze than consciousness.