Knowledge Tree
Relations (1)
related 5.46 — strongly supporting 43 facts
Dualism and physicalism are the two primary, competing metaphysical frameworks used to explain the nature of consciousness, as evidenced by their frequent juxtaposition in philosophical literature [1], [2], and [3]. Many theories, such as panpsychism and Russellian monism, are specifically developed as alternatives or middle grounds to resolve the perceived inadequacies or stalemates between these two positions [4], [5], [6], and [7].
Facts (43)
Sources
Non-physicalist Theories of Consciousness cambridge.org 7 facts
claimThe 'solving two problems at once' argument, which posits that dual-aspect monism avoids the problems of physicalism and dualism, is considered the most important argument for the dual-aspect monism view.
claimThe term 'emergentism' is ambiguous because it is used to describe various kinds of physicalism, as well as views that are indeterminate between physicalism and dualism.
claimA significant minority of philosophers and theorists reject physicalism in favor of theories such as dualism, idealism, and panpsychism.
claimThe hypothesis that consciousness is superposition-resistant is compatible with both dualism and physicalism, as the physicalist version posits that the physical basis of consciousness is what is superposition-resistant.
claimDualism may lead to epiphenomenalism, while physicalism is argued by some to deny the existence of phenomenal consciousness by reducing it to mere functioning or physical structure.
perspectiveDualists argue that while physicalism may be simpler and more elegant than dualism, the epistemic gap between the mental and the physical is a datum that is incompatible with physicalism but compatible with dualism.
claimExplaining mental combination leads to problems for dual-aspect monism that are strongly analogous to the problems faced by physicalism and dualism.
Resolving the evolutionary paradox of consciousness link.springer.com 6 facts
perspectiveRussellian panpsychism does not offer a superior explanation for adaptive-seeming correlations compared to physicalism or dualism.
perspectiveRussellian panpsychism avoids the problem of explaining the origin of consciousness, which physicalism fails to answer and dualism addresses by postulating undiscovered fundamental psychophysical laws.
perspectiveExplaining how the character of sensations could be naturally selected is difficult regardless of whether one adopts physicalism, dualism, or panpsychism as a metaphysical perspective on the nature of consciousness.
claimThe sensational associative learning perspective is compatible with physicalism, panpsychism, and dualism, but is not compatible with epiphenomenalism.
claimThe author of 'Resolving the evolutionary paradox of consciousness' asserts that none of the existing metaphysical perspectives on consciousness—including physicalism, dualism, and panpsychism—can easily explain the adaptive-seeming correlations between sensations and fitness via natural selection.
perspectiveThe author of 'Resolving the evolutionary paradox of consciousness' concludes that physicalism, dualism, and panpsychism do not explain adaptive-seeming correlations between sensations and evolutionary fitness via adaptation.
Critique of Panpsychism: Philosophical Coherence and Scientific ... thequran.love 4 facts
perspectivePanpsychism aims to capture the truths of both physicalism, which posits the unity of nature without supernatural mind-stuff, and dualism, which asserts the reality of the mind, by ensuring consciousness is causally relevant.
claimRussellian panpsychism differs from traditional dualism because it does not posit a separate substance of mind, and it differs from standard physicalism because it asserts that current physical science cannot fully describe matter without including consciousness.
claimPanpsychists claim their theory is more parsimonious than dualism or standard physicalism because it assumes one kind of stuff with dual aspects, thereby avoiding the need to explain radical emergence or arbitrary divides between substances.
claimPanpsychism has experienced a notable revival in contemporary philosophy over the last two decades as philosophers seek alternatives to the stalemate between strict physicalism and dualism.
Unknown source 3 facts
referenceThe essay titled 'Philosophical perspectives on consciousness' explores various philosophical perspectives on consciousness, specifically dualism, physicalism, idealism, panpsychism, and non-Western viewpoints.
perspectiveMost philosophers reject dualism in favor of physicalism, which is the philosophical view that everything in the universe, including the mind, is physical.
referenceThe YouTube video titled 'Philp Goff on Dualism About Consciousness' discusses the philosophical perspectives of physicalism, dualism, and panpsychism, including their respective strengths and weaknesses.
Panpsychism (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy/Fall 2025 Edition) plato.stanford.edu 3 facts
claimZach Blaesi (2021) constructed a moral parody argument against panpsychism, suggesting that if one argues that pre-theoretical beliefs about consciousness must be grounded in fundamental experience because physicalism and dualism are inadequate, one should also accept 'panmoralism'—the idea that moral facts are grounded in fundamental normative properties of micro-level entities.
claimRussellian monism is proposed as a potential solution to the problems facing both dualism and physicalism by integrating consciousness into the material world and accounting for the causal role of human consciousness.
perspectiveProponents of panpsychism view the theory as a middle ground between physicalism and dualism.
PANPSYCHISM (Philosophy of Mind Series) - Amazon.com amazon.com 2 facts
perspectiveThe author argues that Galen Strawson's terminology regarding physicalism is confusing because his definition allows for a person to be a 'physicalist' while simultaneously holding views such as neutral monism, dual-aspect monism, dualism, or idealism.
perspectiveThe reviewer argues that panpsychism is not limited to physicalism but can be integrated into any metaphysical system, including neutral monism, dual-aspect monism, dualism, and idealism.
Panpsychism - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy plato.stanford.edu 2 facts
perspectiveProponents of panpsychism view the theory as a middle ground between physicalism and dualism, as it avoids the disunity of dualism and the difficulty physicalism faces in explaining the emergence of consciousness.
claimRussellian monism attempts to avoid the problems of dualism and physicalism by suggesting that conscious states are the intrinsic nature of brain states, meaning the causal action of brain states and conscious states are the same.
Hard problem of consciousness - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org 2 facts
claimSome researchers respond to the hard problem of consciousness by accepting it as real and seeking to develop a theory of consciousness's place in the world by either modifying physicalism or adopting an alternative ontology such as panpsychism or dualism.
perspectiveRichard Brown defends an unorthodox form of Type-C materialism which asserts that the hard problem of consciousness cannot be decided a priori and that physicalism and dualism can only be vindicated through empirical scientific advances.
Philp Goff on Dualism About Consciousness - YouTube youtube.com 2 facts
claimRobinson and Philip Goff discuss the major philosophical perspectives on consciousness, specifically physicalism, dualism, and panpsychism, in the YouTube video titled 'Philp Goff on Dualism About Consciousness'.
claimPhysicalism, dualism, and panpsychism are identified as the major camps in the debate over consciousness by Robinson and Philip Goff.
Mind and Consciousness - St Andrews Encyclopaedia of Theology saet.ac.uk 2 facts
claimThe terms 'dualism', 'materialism', 'physicalism', 'hylomorphism', 'panpsychism', 'holism', and 'idealism' were unknown to biblical authors and early Christian theologians.
claimContemporary theological and philosophical debates regarding mind and consciousness utilize terms such as dualism, materialism/physicalism, hylomorphism, panpsychism, holism, and idealism.
Dualism, Physicalism, and Philosophy of Mind - Capturing Christianity capturingchristianity.com 1 fact
perspectiveThe author of the Capturing Christianity series previously believed that neuroscientific discoveries regarding brain-mental state correlations rendered the dualist belief in consciousness as something 'over and above the physical' to be a gratuitous hypothesis.
Clarifying the differences between physicalism, idealism, dualism ... facebook.com 1 fact
claimDeepak Chopra asserts that there are distinct philosophical perspectives on the nature of consciousness and reality, specifically identifying physicalism, idealism, dualism, panpsychism, and Advaita Vedanta as the frameworks to be clarified.
Consciousness (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy/Fall 2025 ... plato.stanford.edu 1 fact
claimGeneral metaphysical theories of consciousness address the mind-body problem by asking about the ontological status of consciousness relative to the physical world, with responses generally paralleling standard dualism and physicalism.
Dualism about Consciousness - Bibliography - PhilPapers philpapers.org 1 fact
claimPhysical science has no bias in the ontological debate between proponents of physicalism and dualism.
[PDF] Consciousness and Mind - PhilArchive philarchive.org 1 fact
perspectiveMost philosophers reject dualism in favor of physicalism.
David Chalmers - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org 1 fact
perspectiveDavid Chalmers argues for an 'explanatory gap' from the objective to the subjective and criticizes physicalist explanations of mental experience, identifying himself as a dualist.
Panpsychism - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy plato.stanford.edu 1 fact
referenceThe Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry on Panpsychism lists related entries including George Berkeley, consciousness, René Descartes, dualism, emergent properties, epiphenomenalism, Charles Hartshorne, William James, Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, mereology, monism, neutral monism, pantheism, physicalism, qualia, quantum theory and consciousness, Josiah Royce, Baruch Spinoza, Alfred North Whitehead, and Wilhelm Maximilian Wundt.
Philosophical perspectives on consciousness | Humans - Vocal Media vocal.media 1 fact
claimThere is no consensus on the nature or origins of consciousness among the various philosophical perspectives, including dualism, physicalism, idealism, panpsychism, and non-Western philosophies.
Dualism (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy/Winter 2016 Edition) plato.stanford.edu 1 fact
claimArguments against physicalism are also arguments for the irreducible and immaterial nature of the mind, and consequently, arguments for dualism.
(PDF) Physicalism vs. Dualism: Can Consciousness Be Fully ... researchgate.net 1 fact
referenceThe paper titled 'Physicalism vs. Dualism: Can Consciousness Be Fully Explained by Physical Science' examines the metaphysical and epistemological problem of consciousness by analyzing the frameworks of physicalism and dualism.