claim
When considering whether a hypothetical person ('Jones2') created from a slightly modified sperm and the same egg would be the same person as the original 'Jones,' there are three potential answers: (i) the person either would or would not have existed, but it is unknowable; (ii) there is no fact of the matter regarding existence; or (iii) the person would have existed to some degree or in some ways, possessing an overlap of psychic constitution with the original.
Authors
Sources
- Dualism (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy/Winter 2016 Edition) plato.stanford.edu via serper